Continuing the saga of the misbehaving MPPT....
I'm coming around to the idea it may be faulty, the two that work are showing the correct battery voltage and the third (the naughty misbehaving one) has the voltage cycling over about 5-10s from 55v down to 38v, then jumping back up to 55v and repeat... Which may explain also explain the cycling idle, flick to 30-150w charge, then back to idle.
They are all wired off the same lynx distributor 1000, I haven't been over to check the actual voltages, but the cycle speed is a bit quick for my multimeter to keep track.