This site is now in read-only archive mode. Please move all discussion, and create a new account at the new Victron Community site.
When AC load is less than PV, such that the surplus is correctly directed to charging, why isnt "bulk" shown ?
At the point of transition (from discharge to charge) "bulk" is correctly displayed, but only briefly displayed - as the PV surplus, and therefore the charge current increases "discharging" is displayed, rather than bulk.
If this is expected behaviour it seems rather anti logic. This screencap illustrates.
On the battery the amps say -19 amps so it is discharging
have you got DC loads as well and a BMV connected.
please advise a full diagram of the units connected would help
also make sure its on the latest firmware as well
Some context, and a rewording of the question.
Battery data is from an external BMS, the image shown is correct, current direction might mislead some - its charging.
Perhaps I could have asked - where is the discharge/bulk status displayed derived from ?
"Bulk" is correctly displayed briefly during the transition from discharge to charge - and discharge is correctly displayed when current is being drawn from the battery.
Well the CCGX dose not think so as its showing on the display I would say, change the battery monitor to the multiplus II and see what happens.
maybe turn on DC Loads display in the CCGX and see if that helps you track it down
the numbers dont add up on the display, garbage in garbage out
Paul, there is no Victron battery monitor connected.
As per my previous comment, battery data is from an external BMS.
"Discharging" is correctly displayed when current is being drawn from the battery.
"bulk" is correctly displayed (briefly) when PV output exceeds the AC loads, but as the PV surplus increases, the charge current correctly increase, "discharging" is displayed.
Hence my, where is the displayed status derived from ?
To illustrate that bulk is correctly shown at the point of transition from discharge to charge (here shown charging.
Also, to illustrate how discharging is incorrectly shown as the charge rate is increased past the transition point.
What BMS are you using? any chance the current sensor can be wired / mounted incorrectly?
WM4 - the shunt is correct.
The battery +/- might confuse some, but its correct - and the system is working as expected.
I'm just trying to identify what is controlling the absorb/discharging/bulk text display - it's more for factual correctness rather than incorrect system function.
the +/- is coming from your bms AFAIK
can you show a screenshot of the BMS page?
On ESS systems I don't look at what the Multi is displaying, usually it's Bulk, except when battery is almost full, than it's absorption.
Yes, all of the battery data is coming from the BMS, I suspect the +/- is a red herring as "discharging" is correctly displayed during a discharge (and when it should be "bulk") - the bulk LED on the MP is lit, as you say, untill absorb.
Other than the state display being somewhat random the system is fully functional.
I'll have a look at the bus state log shortly.
How are you getting those nice neat screens shots of just the data ?
My bus data doesnt appear to reflect what the system is doing, as per the DC V/I data.
It's not a answer to this but mine is doing the same thing? plenty of surplus pv power but if you look at the bottom where it says 'MultiPlus-I| 12/3000/120-50 2x120V Discharging" when the battery shows charging this had been since day one. It might be a Firmware issue? The system is all Victron where possible. Except the batteries I have 2 Battle Born Game changers, 4 Rich solar 200 Watt 12v panels. 2 more on the way. The Victron hardware is a Multi plus II, 150/100 MPPT, a Lynx distributor and Shunt. A Cerbo GX 50.
