question

deandavis1 avatar image
deandavis1 asked

BatteryProtect used in solar charging

Hello. I'm looking at the correct way to use Victron's BatteryProtect (BP) and have a number of questions about using it in the solar charging circuit.

The following is the suggested wiring from Victron's website:

A simplified version of the charging circuit for my application is as follows:

The existing BMS would trigger the BP to switch off in the event of overcharging or balance problem etc.

I understand the BP should "never have reverse current from a battery source" (from the product page). My questions are as follows:

1. Wouldn't it make sense to cut power on the PV side of the controller so it is not running without a battery connected? I understand the BP is only rated to 36v and any PV system over this would require some other form of switching.

2. If the MPPT was set to Absorption at 13.9v and Float at 13.6v, then as the MPPT switches to Float the battery voltage is higher. Does this cause a revers current problem?

3. At night (or when the solar is insufficient) the voltage is higher on the OUT terminal than the IN. Effectively the controller is powered by the battery (while a very small current). Isn't this a problem?

4. In the previous point, if the BP activates (disconnects) when the battery voltage is higher than the MPPT then isn't this a problem?

4. If the battery is disconnected (either via the BP or Breaker) then the SmartBatterry Sense is still connected to the battery while the MPPT is not. Would this put the MPPT into a state where its trying to raise the voltage and go into significant over voltage? Then what would happen if the battery reconnects?

5. Given the way the MPPT uses the SmartBattery sense (ie slowly adjusts to compensate for voltage differences) wouldn't this result in the MPPT recording (to store in history) incorrect minimum battery voltages at night through the BP?

I've considered using a 200A contactor but it takes too much hold current. Then I started to think about using a Solid Sate Relay with MOSFET but thought all of the above would be an issue. This lead me to the Victron BP but I'm guessing (maybe incorrectly). the BP has the same problems?

I've read the other threads here on BP but considered this to be a slightly different set of question (and of course not an answer) to warrant its own thread. Sorry if its felt to be duplication.

Thanks in advance and sorry if my understanding of the BP is incorrect.

Battery Protect
screen-shot-2019-09-25-at-120802-pm.png (244.8 KiB)
screen-shot-2019-09-25-at-123759-pm.png (511.2 KiB)
2 |3000
Toggle Comment visibility. Current Visibility: Viewable by all users

Up to 8 attachments (including images) can be used with a maximum of 190.8 MiB each and 286.6 MiB total.

2 Answers
deandavis1 avatar image
deandavis1 answered ·

Hopefully someone at Victron can answer these questions soon. One more to add...


6. Could you please tell me the maximum voltage drop at rated current for both 220 and 100 Battery Protect products.


Thanks again.

2 |3000
Toggle Comment visibility. Current Visibility: Viewable by all users

Up to 8 attachments (including images) can be used with a maximum of 190.8 MiB each and 286.6 MiB total.

Guy Stewart (Victron Community Manager) avatar image
Guy Stewart (Victron Community Manager) answered ·

1 cut power on the PV side

The Battery protect is designed and rated to cut high current, not high voltage. So it is better on the battery side.

2 If the MPPT was set to Absorption at 13.9v and Float at 13.6v, then as the MPPT switches to Float the battery voltage is higher. Does this cause a revers current problem?

Momentary reverse currents such as in this situation are acceptable. The battery voltage will drop almost immediately once the charge current is taken away.

3 At night (or when the solar is insufficient) the voltage is higher on the OUT terminal than the IN. Effectively the controller is powered by the battery (while a very small current). Isn't this a problem?

This load is milliamps, easily able to be dissipated and is within the allowable amount of reverse current.

4 In the previous point, if the BP activates (disconnects) when the battery voltage is higher than the MPPT then isn't this a problem?

No, there will not be any meaningful current flow from the battery to the MPPT in this case. The MPPT and solar array is not a load as such.

5 If the battery is disconnected (either via the BP or Breaker) then the SmartBatterry Sense is still connected to the battery while the MPPT is not. Would this put the MPPT into a state where its trying to raise the voltage and go into significant over voltage? Then what would happen if the battery reconnects?

The MPPT will only ever raise itself to its target voltage. As soon as the battery reconnects, the battery will draw down the voltage to battery level again.

6 Given the way the MPPT uses the SmartBattery sense (ie slowly adjusts to compensate for voltage differences) wouldn't this result in the MPPT recording (to store in history) incorrect minimum battery voltages at night through the BP?

I cannot say for sure one if this one affects accuracy. But I haven't heard any complaints yet either. It might. I would hope that the batteries are not regularly in a state where the battery protect is active (that's a fault?), and if it is, there is some other indicator for your system that there is a problem (than the VictronConnect MPPT history chart).

2 |3000
Toggle Comment visibility. Current Visibility: Viewable by all users

Up to 8 attachments (including images) can be used with a maximum of 190.8 MiB each and 286.6 MiB total.